Pages

▼

Saturday, November 21, 2026

If run a retro-clone or old D&D version, which one?

I own more than a few OSR and retro-clone game systems. I tried to take a complete inventory of print books on my shelves.

Retro-clones and OSR games:

Dungeon Crawl Classics

Labryinth Lord - original, and Advanced Edition Companion

Advanced Labryinth Lord

Basic Fantasy Role-playing Game

Adventurer Conquerer King

Swords & Wizardry Complete

In PDF but not print, I own:

Dark Dungeons

Adventures Dark & Deep

OSRIC (including the most recent Kickstarted version.)

A few different variants of Swords & Wizardry

For official sets, I also own:

Basic Set (Holmes)

Basic Set / Expert Set (Moldvay/Cook)

BECMI (all individual books plus the BECMI compendium in PDF)

AD&D 1st edition (almost everything of any note)

I've looked at Old-School Essentials but I haven't gotten a copy.

I've been thinking of giving a go to running one of them as a small side project. But which one?

I am very much swayed by the simplicity of Basic / Expert. The adventurers are a mixed bag, much more than AD&D.

I am a native citizen of 1st edition AD&D. But I do deeply love the simpler stat effects of Basic Set. And I deeply love how B/X does Morale. Yes, AD&D does it to, but it rarely gets used as isn't as simple or obvious. AD&D can be a hot mess, but OSRIC helps enormously, and it's a pretty deep game in terms of adventures and monsters and such.

Ascending AC makes the most sense, but I understand 10 to -10 as a system very well. Basic Set's 9-down system means the numbers in my head are wrong. I started briefly with Basic Set but immediately got pulled into AD&D and spent my formative years there. So I never really had that different AC system to learn.

So I'm torn. All of the above have their upsides. LL and ALL are quite well done. Basic Fantasy is cheap and easy - everyone can get the rules in the print for very little. ACKS and DCC are very much setting-embedded, which is both good and bad. AD&D is a hot mess, and always has been, so I'd need to do it through OSRIC and probably create endless questions from my players about which book to trust on what. BECMI is probably out - I'd run B/X and just draw on BECMI elements, probably. Swords & Wizardry Complete is easy and a one-book solution.

I'm not sure. I'd like to give one a go, but it'll take some thought to which one. This post is the first part of getting these thoughts out in writing.

2 comments:

  1. Old School Essentials seems to be a very popular retroclone and there’s a ridiculous sale right now on https://www.fanatical.com/en/bundle/old-school-essentials-rpg-collection. Apparently Shadowdark is also very hot.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I saw that - $9 for the core rules and some adventures is nice. But I'd need to get that book printed somehow and that's not going to be quite as cheap.

      And is it really better than B/X D&D or any of the others above? I don't know. It always feels like there is a shiny new retro-clone that's better than all the ones before. But is it? I'm not so sure.

      Delete