I own more than a few OSR and retro-clone game systems. I tried to take a complete inventory of print books on my shelves.
Retro-clones and OSR games:
Dungeon Crawl Classics
Labryinth Lord - original, and Advanced Edition Companion
Advanced Labryinth Lord
Basic Fantasy Role-playing Game
Adventurer Conquerer King
Swords & Wizardry Complete
In PDF but not print, I own:
Dark Dungeons
Adventures Dark & Deep
OSRIC (including the most recent Kickstarted version.)
A few different variants of Swords & Wizardry
For official sets, I also own:
Basic Set (Holmes)
Basic Set / Expert Set (Moldvay/Cook)
BECMI (all individual books plus the BECMI compendium in PDF)
AD&D 1st edition (almost everything of any note)
I've looked at Old-School Essentials but I haven't gotten a copy.
I've been thinking of giving a go to running one of them as a small side project. But which one?
I am very much swayed by the simplicity of Basic / Expert. The adventurers are a mixed bag, much more than AD&D.
I am a native citizen of 1st edition AD&D. But I do deeply love the simpler stat effects of Basic Set. And I deeply love how B/X does Morale. Yes, AD&D does it to, but it rarely gets used as isn't as simple or obvious. AD&D can be a hot mess, but OSRIC helps enormously, and it's a pretty deep game in terms of adventures and monsters and such.
Ascending AC makes the most sense, but I understand 10 to -10 as a system very well. Basic Set's 9-down system means the numbers in my head are wrong. I started briefly with Basic Set but immediately got pulled into AD&D and spent my formative years there. So I never really had that different AC system to learn.
So I'm torn. All of the above have their upsides. LL and ALL are quite well done. Basic Fantasy is cheap and easy - everyone can get the rules in the print for very little. ACKS and DCC are very much setting-embedded, which is both good and bad. AD&D is a hot mess, and always has been, so I'd need to do it through OSRIC and probably create endless questions from my players about which book to trust on what. BECMI is probably out - I'd run B/X and just draw on BECMI elements, probably. Swords & Wizardry Complete is easy and a one-book solution.
I'm not sure. I'd like to give one a go, but it'll take some thought to which one. This post is the first part of getting these thoughts out in writing.
Dungeon Fantastic
Old School informed GURPS Dungeon Fantasy gaming. Basically killing owlbears and taking their stuff, but with 3d6.
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Sponsoring what I use
I finally broke down and decided to sponsor two things I use a lot:
Tenkar's Tavern
GURPS Game Aid for Foundry
I didn't throw much in, but I did put in some money monthly. I usually keep my business to myself, but I want to highlight these two. If it helps get a few more of you to support these two, I'm happy to let everyone know.
Tenkar's Tavern is a great resource for old-school gaming, from a no-nonsense GM. One who, by the way, gives page references. You won't catch him complaining about a module's ambiguity when you know it's clarified in the next room description, or quoting a rule that isn't in the books, or what have you. He puts in the time and work to be right.
GURPS Game Aid? My group is a heavy user of the product. We use it endlessly and I complain about VTT issues a lot. I put money into Foundry and into The Forge to host it, so now I'm putting some into GURPS Game Aid to keep it playable for my system of choice.
Tenkar's Tavern
GURPS Game Aid for Foundry
I didn't throw much in, but I did put in some money monthly. I usually keep my business to myself, but I want to highlight these two. If it helps get a few more of you to support these two, I'm happy to let everyone know.
Tenkar's Tavern is a great resource for old-school gaming, from a no-nonsense GM. One who, by the way, gives page references. You won't catch him complaining about a module's ambiguity when you know it's clarified in the next room description, or quoting a rule that isn't in the books, or what have you. He puts in the time and work to be right.
GURPS Game Aid? My group is a heavy user of the product. We use it endlessly and I complain about VTT issues a lot. I put money into Foundry and into The Forge to host it, so now I'm putting some into GURPS Game Aid to keep it playable for my system of choice.
Monday, November 16, 2026
Some of my favorite quotes from B2 The Keep on the Borderlands
Apropos running the Caves of Chaos yesterday, here are some of my favorite quotes from it:
Back in 1981, when I started, it wasn't assumed you'd be heroes. Nothing like +600 XP for being good, or +600 XP for being evil, depending on what you claim to be. Lawful? Burn them. Chaotic? Read away!
The player tips on page 25 are gold for Basic D&D, but two paragraphs are just gold for everyone in any game that I run or play.
Too much risk and too much caution are equally dangerous. If you only act quickly and boldly, you're going to get killed. If you only act with caution, you're going to die. This is as true in GURPS DF with ~400 point guys and it is in B/X D&D with 1st level characters.
My top quote?
This. Just this. The challenge of thinking is a great of the fun of the game.
(If the party opts to destroy the evil writings, they should receive an additional 600 experience points for the act, unless they are themselves evil, in which case they should receive points for reading these works.)
Back in 1981, when I started, it wasn't assumed you'd be heroes. Nothing like +600 XP for being good, or +600 XP for being evil, depending on what you claim to be. Lawful? Burn them. Chaotic? Read away!
The player tips on page 25 are gold for Basic D&D, but two paragraphs are just gold for everyone in any game that I run or play.
Caution is also necessary and is a part of planning. A party
that charges forward without preparation is almost
certainly doomed. Danger should be expected at any
moment and from any direction, possibly even from one’s
own party. Lying and trickery are not unknown. Cautious
play will help avoid many (but not all) tricks and traps and
may save a life. However, too much caution is as danger-
ous as too little. Many instances will require bold and quick
actions on the part of the players, before all is lost.
Too much risk and too much caution are equally dangerous. If you only act quickly and boldly, you're going to get killed. If you only act with caution, you're going to die. This is as true in GURPS DF with ~400 point guys and it is in B/X D&D with 1st level characters.
My top quote?
Above all a player must think. The game is designed to challenge the minds and imaginations of the players. Those who tackle problems and use their abilities, wits, and new ideas will succeed more often than fail. The challenge of thinking is a great deal of the fun of the game.
This. Just this. The challenge of thinking is a great of the fun of the game.
Sunday, November 15, 2026
GURPS DF Session 228 - Caves of Chaos 11 - Everburning Torch Test
Date: 11/15/2026
Characters
Chop, human cleric (367 points)
Almaric, human squire
Hugo the Wise, human sage
Harold, human guard
Samuel, human guard
Oxford, human laborer
Bullworth, human laborer
Hannari Ironhand, dwarf martial artist (360 points)
Rogar Thane-Blood, human barbarian (259 points)
Thor Halfskepna, human knight (373 points)
The group headed out of town on 11/1, going to the Falcon's Keep on the way to the Caves of Chaos. They first hired a sage (to map), a guard for the sage, and some laborers and guards. The plan was Chop's. He'd recalled a six-fingered humanoid etching on the wall of the Caves of Chaos, with a torch bracket that didn't do anything special. It also depicted a torch with twinned lighting bolt handles . . . and they now had about five of them, swiped from the Brotherhood Complex during a trip by Hannari and Chop.
Once the PCs arrived at the caves, they couldn't remember what cave had the room with the torch bracket. So they started at the top, 100' off the ground. In the they went, right into a storm of arrows. Six arrows, five hits - Thor blocked one he spotted coming at the last moment. Rogar's armor bounced an arrow, Harold dropped with two arrows in his torso, one hit Almaric in the leg. Chop got to work healing while the others charged.
In the next room were six gnolls, who dropped their bows and readied axes. They were dropped in a few seconds, as Rogar hacked one down, Hannari spiked two with thrown kama, and Thor decapitated three of them. One of Hannari's foes was hit in the back as he turned to run.
They rushed down the hallway and found a passage right and a room ahead. They chose the room and ran into 18 gnolls - six males with poleaxes, twelve somewhat smaller females with spears. The gnolls rushed them, and Rogar rushed them back. In a few seconds, the fight was over. Thor decapitated gnoll after gnoll, Hannari spiked a few and then beat one down with nunchaku and an axe, and Rogar put a few down with axe shots. Three managed to surrender after the other fifteen(!) were dead or dying.
With Gift of Tongues, Chop convinced them to take him to their leader. They did, bypassing a room with females, children, and males ready to fight, and into the chief's room.
The Chief negotiated with them - they wanted guidance to the temple. They said they'd show the PCs to the Cave of Death but not go on. Chop agreed. They left, leaving 21 dead behind them and a shaken gnoll tribe.
They entered the Cave of Death. They could smell faint decay and felt evil. Thor was a little unnerved by it. The complex echoed with their footsteps, and Chop could hear some faint piping. The walls were shot with black and red veins, and it was Low Sanctity.
Long story short, they searched the place thoroughly, Chop using See Secrets. They found the torch bracket and the etching of the six-fingered figure on the wall (details in the link above.) They put the torch in the bracket. Nothing happened. It couldn't be pushed, pulled, twisted, or turned. Reversing the torch didn't help. It fit - and fit perfectly - but didn't do anything but burn without fuel like they normally do underground.
The PCs left it there, and explored the nearby main temple - Thor sat on the throne (to no effect) while Hannari and Chop investigated the glassy wall behind it. They were quickly entranced, and began to chant and sing and dance in an errie manner. Thor and Rogar dragged them from the wall after pokes and yells did nothing. Neither looked at the creepy wall as they did so.
Once everyone was safe, they went back into the temple and rang the big bell that was there. But nothing happened except that two of their NPCs ran off. Thor chased them down and rallied them with Leadership.
After, they explored the rest of the complex. They found more looted areas, a guest room with old furniture in it, a torture chamber with a matress in the corner (slit in the corner, loot clearing taken from within), and then a looted storeroom with a secret door. They went through it, and through another - and surprised the gnoll chief! It lead into a covered wall area in the gnoll's room. They apologized and left, and heard furniture piled up against the secret door.
One final room - a steel-doored cell - was opened and searched. They found six skeletons of long-dead prisoners.
At that, it was already well into night at the Caves, so they left and headed back to the keep, and then back to Stericksburg.
Notes:
- Surprise drop-in for Thor, whose player wasn't expected but finished up other tasks early.
- Hannari was disappointed that the final remnants of the Black Brotherhood hadn't retreated to here - after getting kicked out of Felltower and then the Brotherhood Complex. It wasn't to be.
I'm curious what the story of the Black Brotherhood looks like from the player's side of the screen. Hannari's half-joking lament was a clue, but I'm curious what they've assembled into what kind of story. If one of my players writes it, I'll share it.
- This was a very pricy delve for the PCs - $3K for the two expert hirelings, $2.4K for the guards and laborers, and not a single copper piece of loot. But they did answer a question, and did show a link between the Caves of Chaos and the six-fingered vampires also known as the Gith. It didn't reveal anything exciting, but it did show the connection and answer the "what if" question.
- the fights were walkovers. The gnolls are fodder - not even as tough as the gnolls in Felltower, and those are still fodder. Had they hit on every shot they'd still all have died but just dealt a bit of damage on the way down. The PCs didn't bother to loot them in the interest of speed of delve, and then didn't once they'd establish a truce. But they killed roughly 1/3 of the whole tribe in seconds and only took a few arrow his and a mild slice to Rogar's arm from a poleaxe in return.
- No loot, so it was 1 xp exploration, 1 xp for solving a long-standing mystery, and MVP was Chop for his push to try this delve.
Next game is in a couple of weeks.
Characters
Chop, human cleric (367 points)
Almaric, human squire
Hugo the Wise, human sage
Harold, human guard
Samuel, human guard
Oxford, human laborer
Bullworth, human laborer
Hannari Ironhand, dwarf martial artist (360 points)
Rogar Thane-Blood, human barbarian (259 points)
Thor Halfskepna, human knight (373 points)
The group headed out of town on 11/1, going to the Falcon's Keep on the way to the Caves of Chaos. They first hired a sage (to map), a guard for the sage, and some laborers and guards. The plan was Chop's. He'd recalled a six-fingered humanoid etching on the wall of the Caves of Chaos, with a torch bracket that didn't do anything special. It also depicted a torch with twinned lighting bolt handles . . . and they now had about five of them, swiped from the Brotherhood Complex during a trip by Hannari and Chop.
Once the PCs arrived at the caves, they couldn't remember what cave had the room with the torch bracket. So they started at the top, 100' off the ground. In the they went, right into a storm of arrows. Six arrows, five hits - Thor blocked one he spotted coming at the last moment. Rogar's armor bounced an arrow, Harold dropped with two arrows in his torso, one hit Almaric in the leg. Chop got to work healing while the others charged.
In the next room were six gnolls, who dropped their bows and readied axes. They were dropped in a few seconds, as Rogar hacked one down, Hannari spiked two with thrown kama, and Thor decapitated three of them. One of Hannari's foes was hit in the back as he turned to run.
They rushed down the hallway and found a passage right and a room ahead. They chose the room and ran into 18 gnolls - six males with poleaxes, twelve somewhat smaller females with spears. The gnolls rushed them, and Rogar rushed them back. In a few seconds, the fight was over. Thor decapitated gnoll after gnoll, Hannari spiked a few and then beat one down with nunchaku and an axe, and Rogar put a few down with axe shots. Three managed to surrender after the other fifteen(!) were dead or dying.
With Gift of Tongues, Chop convinced them to take him to their leader. They did, bypassing a room with females, children, and males ready to fight, and into the chief's room.
The Chief negotiated with them - they wanted guidance to the temple. They said they'd show the PCs to the Cave of Death but not go on. Chop agreed. They left, leaving 21 dead behind them and a shaken gnoll tribe.
They entered the Cave of Death. They could smell faint decay and felt evil. Thor was a little unnerved by it. The complex echoed with their footsteps, and Chop could hear some faint piping. The walls were shot with black and red veins, and it was Low Sanctity.
Long story short, they searched the place thoroughly, Chop using See Secrets. They found the torch bracket and the etching of the six-fingered figure on the wall (details in the link above.) They put the torch in the bracket. Nothing happened. It couldn't be pushed, pulled, twisted, or turned. Reversing the torch didn't help. It fit - and fit perfectly - but didn't do anything but burn without fuel like they normally do underground.
The PCs left it there, and explored the nearby main temple - Thor sat on the throne (to no effect) while Hannari and Chop investigated the glassy wall behind it. They were quickly entranced, and began to chant and sing and dance in an errie manner. Thor and Rogar dragged them from the wall after pokes and yells did nothing. Neither looked at the creepy wall as they did so.
Once everyone was safe, they went back into the temple and rang the big bell that was there. But nothing happened except that two of their NPCs ran off. Thor chased them down and rallied them with Leadership.
After, they explored the rest of the complex. They found more looted areas, a guest room with old furniture in it, a torture chamber with a matress in the corner (slit in the corner, loot clearing taken from within), and then a looted storeroom with a secret door. They went through it, and through another - and surprised the gnoll chief! It lead into a covered wall area in the gnoll's room. They apologized and left, and heard furniture piled up against the secret door.
One final room - a steel-doored cell - was opened and searched. They found six skeletons of long-dead prisoners.
At that, it was already well into night at the Caves, so they left and headed back to the keep, and then back to Stericksburg.
Notes:
- Surprise drop-in for Thor, whose player wasn't expected but finished up other tasks early.
- Hannari was disappointed that the final remnants of the Black Brotherhood hadn't retreated to here - after getting kicked out of Felltower and then the Brotherhood Complex. It wasn't to be.
I'm curious what the story of the Black Brotherhood looks like from the player's side of the screen. Hannari's half-joking lament was a clue, but I'm curious what they've assembled into what kind of story. If one of my players writes it, I'll share it.
- This was a very pricy delve for the PCs - $3K for the two expert hirelings, $2.4K for the guards and laborers, and not a single copper piece of loot. But they did answer a question, and did show a link between the Caves of Chaos and the six-fingered vampires also known as the Gith. It didn't reveal anything exciting, but it did show the connection and answer the "what if" question.
- the fights were walkovers. The gnolls are fodder - not even as tough as the gnolls in Felltower, and those are still fodder. Had they hit on every shot they'd still all have died but just dealt a bit of damage on the way down. The PCs didn't bother to loot them in the interest of speed of delve, and then didn't once they'd establish a truce. But they killed roughly 1/3 of the whole tribe in seconds and only took a few arrow his and a mild slice to Rogar's arm from a poleaxe in return.
- No loot, so it was 1 xp exploration, 1 xp for solving a long-standing mystery, and MVP was Chop for his push to try this delve.
Next game is in a couple of weeks.
Sunday, November 8, 2026
Felltower: Increase Upkeep for high-point characters
Felltower allows for extra spending on upkeep in town for a bonus to all rolls in town. You pay your listed upkeep. x2 is a +1, x4 is a +2, etc.
People just won't spend extra in town willingly. So pretty much we have almost 400 point characters with nearly six figures in cash plus outstanding mundane and magical gear spending $150 a week on upkeep in town.
A solution? Increased expected cost of living based on your point value. The better you are, the better people expect you to live. For every tier or partial tier below this you spend, you get a -1 to all rolls in town. You live shabby when you're supposedly rich, and people will look down on you.
Points Cost of Upkeep (Option 1) Cost of Upkeep (Option 2)
1) 299 or fewer points $150 $100
2) 300-349 points $300 $200
3) 350-399 points $600 $400
4) 400-449 points $1,200 $1,000
5) 450-549 points $2,250 $4,000
6) 550 or more points $6,000 $20,000
Optionally: Every additional 50 points = x2 and x10, respectively
The first is based on upkeep costs as they exist now. The second is basically saying your minimum loot for full xp is also the minimum upkeep people expect you to spend. I doubt I'd get any takes on the 2nd level but it has the beauty of being the same scale - and a reason why "we just made our look threshold" should be a relief not a reason to celebrate. You've broken even, and too many delves without loot will quickly reduce a big pile of saved cash to nothing.
The objections you'll get to this is:
- my character has Miserliness
- my character's take a vow of poverty for everything except usual adventuring gear
- my character doesn't care if anyone likes him or not
- my character is secretly wealthy and doesn't want anyone to know about it
People just won't spend extra in town willingly. So pretty much we have almost 400 point characters with nearly six figures in cash plus outstanding mundane and magical gear spending $150 a week on upkeep in town.
A solution? Increased expected cost of living based on your point value. The better you are, the better people expect you to live. For every tier or partial tier below this you spend, you get a -1 to all rolls in town. You live shabby when you're supposedly rich, and people will look down on you.
Points Cost of Upkeep (Option 1) Cost of Upkeep (Option 2)
1) 299 or fewer points $150 $100
2) 300-349 points $300 $200
3) 350-399 points $600 $400
4) 400-449 points $1,200 $1,000
5) 450-549 points $2,250 $4,000
6) 550 or more points $6,000 $20,000
Optionally: Every additional 50 points = x2 and x10, respectively
The first is based on upkeep costs as they exist now. The second is basically saying your minimum loot for full xp is also the minimum upkeep people expect you to spend. I doubt I'd get any takes on the 2nd level but it has the beauty of being the same scale - and a reason why "we just made our look threshold" should be a relief not a reason to celebrate. You've broken even, and too many delves without loot will quickly reduce a big pile of saved cash to nothing.
The objections you'll get to this is:
- my character has Miserliness
- my character's take a vow of poverty for everything except usual adventuring gear
- my character doesn't care if anyone likes him or not
- my character is secretly wealthy and doesn't want anyone to know about it
- my character is a martial artist and cares not to spend money on worldly things (besides that x2 built into the template)
- my character is a cleric and lives a simple life at the church
etc.
Most of this is effectively BS, because there are real life people who have millions and drive a battered old car and live in a small house . . . but those aren't really an example of what adventurers do. In a dungeon delving game, you're coming back to town and cashing in $60K gear as loot, hauling up boxes of silver coins, selling off fistfuls of gems, and buying magical custom-made weapons and armor. Nevermind the dropping silver by the pound at the potion shop. This is, like it or not, very visible spending and very visible consumption. Miserly folks can save the cash but get a bad reaction roll modifier for being cheap (and merchants won't be breaking the bank stocking up gear you might need - you're probably going to say no and not buy it, tying up their capital.) Clerics can live in a monastic cell, sure, but if they tithe a huge pile of loot to the church people will treat them nicely, and if they live in a monastic cell but don't donate to the church people will know they're not a good priest. Martial artists need to support their temple or dojo or school.
etc.
Most of this is effectively BS, because there are real life people who have millions and drive a battered old car and live in a small house . . . but those aren't really an example of what adventurers do. In a dungeon delving game, you're coming back to town and cashing in $60K gear as loot, hauling up boxes of silver coins, selling off fistfuls of gems, and buying magical custom-made weapons and armor. Nevermind the dropping silver by the pound at the potion shop. This is, like it or not, very visible spending and very visible consumption. Miserly folks can save the cash but get a bad reaction roll modifier for being cheap (and merchants won't be breaking the bank stocking up gear you might need - you're probably going to say no and not buy it, tying up their capital.) Clerics can live in a monastic cell, sure, but if they tithe a huge pile of loot to the church people will treat them nicely, and if they live in a monastic cell but don't donate to the church people will know they're not a good priest. Martial artists need to support their temple or dojo or school.
I'm strongly debating going with Option 1 for Felltower. It would fit the game. I honestly expected people would spend more in town but I was wrong - no one spends a dime more than they have to, and hoard everything for dungeon gear. Sensible for a paper man, but doesn't pass the believability test.
Saturday, November 7, 2026
I kept Tenkar's cursed sword
Just saying. I'm one of the people who kept the cursed sword Tenkar is talking about in this video.
Mirado the Black couldn't get enough of Woundlicker.
Mirado the Black couldn't get enough of Woundlicker.
Monday, November 2, 2026
Skill Cap & Fixed Effect Potions
I have to get final buy-in from my players, but I think we're doing the following:
Hard Base Skill Cap of 30. No matter how you get there, the hard limit on your base skill will be 30, before any negative modifiers are factored in.
For example: DX 20, +3 DX from a potion, DX+8 in Axe/Mace, four levels of Pickaxe Penchant for a base DX 24 for this skill, and a Balanced weapon with Accuracy 3 on it. 20 + 3 + 8 + 4 + 1 + 3 = 39 skill, reduced to 30. Only now do you add in the penalties for hit location, range, bad footing, shock, etc. -4 DX from being grappled? That comes after.
This is pretty harsh, but skill 30 is already enough to inflict Deceptive Attack -7 to all defenses and still have a skill 16 - where 3-6 crits, 17 misses, and 18 critically misses.
This does mean you're not really better off getting higher than a 25-26 skill, if only to leave room for the effect of maneuvers and magical weaponry and DX potions. This isn't a mistake. Diversify. Being Broadsword-30 when you have Wrestling-14 is a design flaw. Maybe it's in-character for your guy, but still.
Fixed Effect Potions
Ability boosting consumables give +3 for 1d of listed effect.*
Healing potions are unaffected, as are any durations, damage rolls, etc.
I'll leave everything else as is.
* I know 4 is actually the average (3.5, rounded normally.) But while +4 ST is nice to have (usually +4 swing, +2 thrust), +4 DX is really amazing. +3 is good enough.
Hard Base Skill Cap of 30. No matter how you get there, the hard limit on your base skill will be 30, before any negative modifiers are factored in.
For example: DX 20, +3 DX from a potion, DX+8 in Axe/Mace, four levels of Pickaxe Penchant for a base DX 24 for this skill, and a Balanced weapon with Accuracy 3 on it. 20 + 3 + 8 + 4 + 1 + 3 = 39 skill, reduced to 30. Only now do you add in the penalties for hit location, range, bad footing, shock, etc. -4 DX from being grappled? That comes after.
This is pretty harsh, but skill 30 is already enough to inflict Deceptive Attack -7 to all defenses and still have a skill 16 - where 3-6 crits, 17 misses, and 18 critically misses.
This does mean you're not really better off getting higher than a 25-26 skill, if only to leave room for the effect of maneuvers and magical weaponry and DX potions. This isn't a mistake. Diversify. Being Broadsword-30 when you have Wrestling-14 is a design flaw. Maybe it's in-character for your guy, but still.
Fixed Effect Potions
Ability boosting consumables give +3 for 1d of listed effect.*
Healing potions are unaffected, as are any durations, damage rolls, etc.
I'll leave everything else as is.
* I know 4 is actually the average (3.5, rounded normally.) But while +4 ST is nice to have (usually +4 swing, +2 thrust), +4 DX is really amazing. +3 is good enough.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)