Thank to my friend and former paladin Tom for finding this:
What if Edward Gorey Illustrated Lovecraft?
The link is to a post on The Lovecraftian, a blog about H. P. Lovecraft over on Wordpress. The post selects the most Lovecraftian pictures by artist Don Kenn. His stuff really does look like Edward Gorey's, but with even more monstrous themes (if that's possible.
Pretty cool, and I fully intend to stat one or two of those guys now. Like maybe these . . .